Is the Bayonet Obsolete?

Discussion in 'General Martial Arts Discussion' started by Darrin Cook, Jan 31, 2010.

  1. Darrin Cook

    Darrin Cook New Member

    I have a new post on my blog about a debate in the US army whether or not to continue bayonet training.

    I was surprised to discover that the bayonet is still used in combat, as recently as the Iraq war.

    I'm curious to find out if anyone uses a bayonet in a home defense situation. I think that a shotgun or a low powered rifle outfitted with a bayonet would be a very effective weapon for the home. I'm uncertain as to its legality, though. I remember that part of the "assault weapons" ban had to do with outlawing bayonet lugs, which somehow made certain guns evil.

    Let me also recommend Cold Steel, a classic book on Marine Corps self-defense with the bayonet, knife, stick, and bare hands. It's an old book, but I don't know how you'd top it.
     
  2. jwinch2

    jwinch2 Member

    I do not have a bayonet on any of my at home weapons and though I feel they are valuable as tools I would be uncomfortable with adding several inches of extra length of a home defense weapon which would make it more difficult to clear a room and maneuver effectively. I currently have the paperwork underway to build a short barreled rifle which may alter my opinions a bit but not so far.

    The other thing to consider is that adding a bayonet to an at home weapon is not going to look good to the LEO's who show up at the scene, a prosecutor, a judge, or jury. Its bad enough that I have an evil black rifle and an equally evil black shotgun. A bayonet would just increase the likelihood that people see things the wrong way.
     
  3. arnisador

    arnisador Active Member

    I understood that a big part of the reason for bayonet training is that the training helps develop an aggressive mindset, and that this was more important than the small chance of it being used.
     
  4. PG Michael B

    PG Michael B Oso Grande

    I have a few bayonets..take them off the weapon and you have a hefty knife.....keep them on the weapon and your ready for zombies. While I do not recommend a bayonet topped ak47 for home defense it damn sure has it's place when mutilating zombies..lol

    As to the US Army still working the bayonet..I say hell yeah...gives them more applicable skills and in a combat zone one never knows when u have to resort to the bayonet.....it also is a major mind melt to the enemy when some crazy SOB starts hard charging your ass with intent to rip you from anus to ear lobe...psy ops 101 right there!
     
  5. Carol

    Carol <font color = blue><b>Technical Administrator</b><

    OK, Devil's Advocate here.

    I don't doubt that bayonet training can help develop an aggressive mindset. But doesn't all most (effective) blade training develop an aggressive mindset? One of my carry blades is a Ka-Bar, which is not that much smaller than the average bayonet.

    If I were to use my Ka-Bar in a self-defense scenario, I would have to get a helluva lot closer to the perp than I would if the blade was attached to the end of a long gun.
     
  6. arnisador

    arnisador Active Member

    With a bayonet you can take a run at a heavy bag and get your whole body into it in a way you wouldn't if you were thinking knife dueling, and you can practice it with padded staves...I think it may edo a better job of getting that "hard-charging" mentality in quickly, to a large group.
     
  7. sjansen

    sjansen New Member

    If your using the normal size k-bar it is larger in length than any current US bayonet.

    The M9 bayonet has a 7 inch blade and the standard K-bar is 8 inches.
     
  8. PG Michael B

    PG Michael B Oso Grande

    NO....not all who train in blade work have the gumption to use it....where as in the military these guys who join infantry and similar units are young hard chargers who more than likely will taste combat in this detonator of a modern world we live in. The blade on the rifle means more to them than others of a civilian kind who simply go to Arnis class. These guys may need it for real time. Also, there is a huge difference in building an aggressive mindset living in relative peace, and developing an aggressive mind set knowing you will be headed to Iraq or Afghanistan...a huge difference!

    Yeah Carol, but when ya go there you'd be packing quality steel ;)...lol..not a bad druther me thinks.

    As to the long end of a gun...LONG STICK GOES BOOM...it is the preferred method...
     
  9. punisher73

    punisher73 Member

    Why? If you are in your own home and are legally defending yourself. Why not shoot them with a shotgun? You have 4 rounds that you can choose between buck shot or slugs, if you opt for a tactical model, you usually have about a 7 shot capacity. Add a side saddle to it for another 6 rounds of ammo on it. You have 13 shots available now to you. Why would you turn the best QCQ weapon available for home defense into a short spear?

    Tactically speaking, it doesn't make sense at all if you goal is to protect your home. If you are close enough to stab them with a bayonet, you are close enough to pull the trigger on them. If you need more than 13 shots at close range with a shotgun, then you need to spend more time out on a range running drills and understanding your weapon.
     
  10. arnisador

    arnisador Active Member

    Army Abandons Bayonets for Calisthenics

    Trainers Hope Building Core Body Muscles Will Toughen Recruits, Better Train Them For Modern Battlefield




     

Share This Page